LAS VEGAS — Ardently liberal, pro-labor and anti-corporate cash, the field of Democrats running for president may look like a union activist's dream. But some key labor leaders are starting to worry about the topics dominating the 2020 conversation.
The candidates are spending too much time talking about esoteric issues like the Senate filibuster and the composition of the Supreme Court and not enough time speaking the language of workers, several union officials said. Those ideas may excite progressive activists, they said, but they risk alienating working-class voters.
“They've got to pay attention to kitchen table economics,” said Ted Pappageorge, president of the Las Vegas Culinary Union that represents 60,000 hotel and casino workers. “We don't quite see that.”
Terry McGowan, president of the International Union of Operating Engineers Local 139, in Wisconsin, said many of the issues driving the 2020 primary so far are distractions.
“The people that are into politics, the people who like sideshows, they're into that,” he said, citing the debates over reparations for slavery and immigration as examples. “The masses just want to feed their families.”
The unease may be an early warning sign for Democrats, who watched as many white, working-class voters, including many union members in key Rust Belt states, chose Trump three years ago. Democrats are hoping to win back some of those voters next year, a challenge that is made harder, some argue, by labor's struggle to build its membership and influence its rank and file. Democrats’ early messages may not help, some said.
“You see where some of the party's being driven. It's no secret,” said Rusty McAllister, executive secretary of the Nevada AFL-CIO.
McAllister pointed to "Medicare for all" — the health care proposal of choice for several candidates — as an example of Democrats' not seizing on labor's top priorities. Many unions already organized and fought for private health insurance for their members. "That's not something that I think that labor is as much focused on as some of the progressives are," McAllister said.
Such concerns — which stretched from the progressive-minded organizing halls of Nevada to the Rust Belt precincts — were typically focused on the conversation, not the candidates. The early 2020 primary has included detours into debates over the Senate filibuster, the composition of the Supreme Court and breaking up technology companies.
Ken Broadbent, business manager of the Pittsburgh-based Steamfitters Local 449, worried that Democrats are too focused on environmental plans like the Green New Deal, a blueprint for shifting the U.S. economy away from fossil fuels, and will neglect the importance of swing state Pennsylvania's rich natural gas deposits in creating jobs.
“Jobs is where we've got to keep things focused,” Broadbent said.
To be sure, many unionists are excited about the presidential field. Contenders include liberal stalwarts like Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders, whose campaign became the first in U.S. history with a unionized workforce, and Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren, who joined striking Stop & Shop workers on a picket line in New Hampshire on Friday. California Sen. Kamala Harris hired a top Service Employees International Union executive for her campaign and made her first proposal one to raise teacher's pay.
Former Vice President Joe Biden made clear that he plans to appeal to union workers, if he gets in the race. “You are coming back,” he told the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers last week. “We need you back.”
Randi Weingarten, president of the American Federation of Teachers, said the competition in the crowded field has amplified workers voices and issues.
She noted that prominent presidential candidates quickly supported Los Angeles public school teachers when they struck in January. Warren, Sanders, Harris and New Jersey Sen. Cory Booker have all proposed various taxes on higher-earning families, a departure from most past Democratic hopefuls who have treaded carefully on the issue.
“It feels different than at other times,” Weingarten said. “There is far more attention and focus on working people's economic needs.”
Major endorsements are likely several months away, especially because the labor movement is treading carefully after complaints that its leadership was too quick to back Hillary Clinton in the 2016 primary over Sanders.
For labor, much is at stake. Despite Republican gains, particularly with trade union members, labor remains an essential part of the Democrats’ coalition. Unions spent $169 million in 2018 on federal elections, largely on Democrats’ behalf, according to the Center for Responsive Politics. Democrats won union workers by a strong 59%-39% margin in 2018, according to AP VoteCast, a national survey of the electorate.
But other big donors and — small, online ones, too — increasingly compete with labor's organizing muscle as key to Democratic victories. Activists on a broad array of issues, from gay rights to criminal justice, compete with unions for candidates’ attention. And the labor movement itself is split on its priorities, with some pushing for a focus on trade while other who represent more diverse workforces want to zoom in on immigration.
All this comes as Republicans have pushed several state laws weakening organized labor. And, last year, the Supreme Court ruled that government workers can't be forced to contribute to the unions that represent them in collective bargaining, dealing a blow to public service union's pocketbooks.
As candidates court unions for endorsements, labor leaders say they are listening for a comeback plan.
Any proposal aimed at workers “must include ensuring the opportunity to join a union, no matter where you work, since that's the best way to raise wages, improve working conditions, create family-sustaining jobs and begin to fix our rigged economy and democracy,” said SEIU president Mary Kay Henry.
At a National Association of Building Trades Unions in Washington on Wednesday, several Democratic contenders talked about outlawing so-called “right to work” laws that prevent unions from automatically deducting dues from members, said the group's president, Sean McGarvey. But, he added, he heard “very little about the actual structural changes to the National Labor Relations Act, or things they could put in place to give people a real free choice to join a union.”
- In Lordstown, Pittsburgh appearances, Bernie Sanders pitches a tougher line than Trump on GM closures
- New phase in 2020 presidential race tests Dems' aggression
- Democratic panel to open debate on reparations for slavery
- Elizabeth Warren challenges Bernie Sanders for progressives' support
- 'Medicare for All's' rich benefits 'leapfrog' other nations
- Bernie Sanders takes aim at Joe Biden's 'middle ground' approach
- Kamala Harris aims to regain spotlight in crowded 2020 field
- Immigration largely absent from Democrats' 2020 policy blitz
- Joe Biden heads to Pennsylvania to pitch rebuilding middle class
- Joe Biden enters Democratic race with strong anti-Trump theme
- Ex-Vice President Joe Biden launches 2020 presidential campaign
- Straight talk on race becoming a must for white candidates
- AP source: Joe Biden to announce 2020 bid on Thursday
- Impeachment, felons voting divides Democrats at CNN forums
- Biden says Trump abused his office, ignored most Americans
- Bernie Sanders finds himself in a new role as front-runner
- Joe Biden to make 1st appearance since complaints about behavior
- Northeast Ohio Representative Tim Ryan announces White House bid (UPDATED, VIDEO)
- Justice reform activists want more ideas from Democratic presidential candidates
- Beto O'Rourke, Bernie Sanders vie for same young voters in 2020 campaign
- In 1st quarter, Bernie Sanders takes early lead in 2020 fundraising
- 2020 by the numbers: Democrats posting big campaign stats
- AP Exclusive: Kamala Harris' call for reform collides with her past
- Joe Biden says he doesn't believe he's acted inappropriately
- Presidential candidate Pete Buttigieg gains with crowds, TV spots and campaign cash
- Joe Biden faces a challenge winning over progressives
- Elizabeth Warren embraces underdog role as she faces 2020 challenges
- Democratic 2020 field taking shape with Beto O'Rourke entry
- Democrat Beto O'Rourke announces 2020 White House bid
- A state Senate race in Iowa draws presidential hopefuls
- Some Democrats in 2020 campaign reaching out to rural areas
- Joe Biden could get boost by back-to-back 2020 departures
- No 2020 White House run for Dem Sen. Sherrod Brown of Ohio (UPDATED)
- Hillary Clinton rules out a rematch with Trump in 2020
- Bill Clinton has 2020 advice, but few candidates seeking it
- Presidential candidate Amy Klobuchar defends her record on regulating medical devices
- Analysis: Bernie Sanders may not need 2016 magic to be 2020 force
- Belles of the ball: Dem freshmen courted by 2020 hopefuls
- Sen. Bernie Sanders says he's running for president in 2020
- 2020 Democrats weigh how to recapture voters in Midwest
- Beyond liberal base, some Democrats pitch to party moderates
- APNewsBreak: South Bend Mayor Pete Buttigieg joins 2020 presidential race
- Democrats lurch left on top policies as 2020 primary begins
- California Senator Kamala Harris jumps into presidential race
- Martin Luther King Jr. holiday represents big moment for 2020 Democrats
- 2020 Democrats face a choice: Fight Trump or ignore him?
- Man in the middle: DNC chair Tom Perez prepares for tough primary
- After Year of the Woman, 2020 buzz so far focuses on the men
- Bernie Sanders eyes 'bigger' 2020 bid despite some warning signs